This is an old thread but I have the same problem. Cars 2 (standard bluray) plays just fine on xbox-one but cannot get past the "opening" on two different systems. LG & Asus, gtx 1070 and 1060 respectively. Seems to be a new disk I just got, looks perfect with no blemishes, but I washed it anyway and still same problem. One system crashed with error message dialog box to report error, the other requested to ignore all or abort. Never gets out of the "opening" phase if I request "ignore all".