Hacksaw Ridge Blu-Ray

Yakster

Hacksaw Ridge is listed on the 2017 Supported List, but as of today 2-27-2017 DVDFab Blu-Ray Copy is not removing the Cinevia protection from my Region 1 US disc. I checked my authorization status which shows my account is active for the Cinevia Blu-Ray removal. I have also verified my settings to ensure that the Cinevia removal is properly setup.

october262

It's on the list but not yet supported.

Yakster

List Reviewed

I examined the 2017 Supported list again, but the text is published in black not blue, green or red. It would appear that it should be supported.

MrVideo

Read the list again, especially the text at the top of the list. If it is in black, the title is infected with Cinavia, but not yet supported.

signals

Yakster, please see this.

"The following list prov[SIZE=2]ide[/SIZE]s the support status for Cinavia-infected titles. [COLOR=Green]Green Text [COLOR=Green]means the title is supported now for the Regions/Countries or versions indicated, Blue Text means the title will be supported very soon, [COLOR=Red]Red=support recently added.[/COLOR] Titles are ordered by release date."[/COLOR][/COLOR]

ARAMP1

This might be the wrong thread for the subject, but I'll ask anyway. I bought the Hacksaw Ridge DVD. The DVDFab warning popped up stating that it was infected with Cinavia. I figured I'd rip the DVD anyway. I did MP4 4K and AC3. My setup is Plex Media Server through a Roku. I didn't notice any problems with the sound at all. So, questions are...

Is there something in the format that I ripped the movie to that didn't support Cinavia?

Is the Cinavia still there and did my setup just by chance not find the encoding to mess with the audio?

october262

[QUOTE=ARAMP1;194122]This might be the wrong thread for the subject, but I'll ask anyway. I bought the Hacksaw Ridge DVD. The DVDFab warning popped up stating that it was infected with Cinavia. I figured I'd rip the DVD anyway. I did MP4 4K and AC3. My setup is Plex Media Server through a Roku. I didn't notice any problems with the sound at all. So, questions are...

Is there something in the format that I ripped the movie to that didn't support Cinavia?

Is the Cinavia still there and did my setup just by chance not find the encoding to mess with the audio?[/QUOTE]

Media players are immune to cinavia

96734-dvd

[QUOTE=october262;194124]Media players are immune to cinavia[/QUOTE]

can you elaborate on this? are you saying, doing a say, 'bluray copy' and playing it on an android box is fine - so no loss of audio. but burning it onto a bluray disk and playing it in bluray player will be problematic? thanks.

90312

Roku is not affected by Cinavia protection. Pick up a Roku at Wal~Mart make a high quality MP4 and forget Cinavia exists.

96734-dvd

[QUOTE=90312;194251]Roku is not affected by Cinavia protection. Pick up a Roku at Wal~Mart make a high quality MP4 and forget Cinavia exists.[/QUOTE]

would that apply to 'bluray copy' and playing it on an android box too?

90312

Yeah it should be the same on those android boxes. If you want to burn disc media you'll need DVDFab Cinavia removal module. I've even burned the MP4 to DVD media and Cinavia muted the audio when played in the BR player.

96734-dvd

[QUOTE=90312;194253]Yeah it should be the same on those android boxes. If you want to burn disc media you'll need DVDFab Cinavia removal module. I've even burned the MP4 to DVD media and Cinavia muted the audio when played in the BR player.[/QUOTE]

awesome. thanks man! you saved ~$100 'cause was just about to purchase cinavia removal, but I never burn discs.

90312

Well it wasn't my intention to knock them out of a sale, but if you are going to play mp4 or mkv files on a media player you really don't need it. And you're welcome.

96734-dvd

[QUOTE=90312;194255]Well it wasn't my intention to knock them out of a sale, but if you are going to play mp4 or mkv files on a media player you really don't need it. And you're welcome.[/QUOTE]

I tried making a 'bluray copy' but it just got stuck at 42%; but you're saying cinavia doesn't have anything to do with 'bluray copy'? and that it should do a copy fine? wondering if I just got a bad one. will have to try and return it.

signals

Blu-ray Copy does just what its name says: it makes a Copy of a Blu-ray as a Blu-ray. You will need Cinavia Removal whether you write the output to a disc or a folder, depending on your player software.

96734-dvd

[QUOTE=signals;194259]Blu-ray Copy does just what its name says: it makes a Copy of a Blu-ray as a Blu-ray. You will need Cinavia Removal whether you write the output to a disc or a folder, depending on your player software.[/QUOTE]

so being stuck at 42% is probably due to cinavia ? I tried both version 9 and 10 and full disc vs. main movie and all 4 tries hung.

96734-dvd

october262

Are you trying full disc or main movie ?? Cinavia removal only
Works with main movie. Also look at the back of the box the disc came
In and tell what audio tracks the disc has.

MrVideo

[QUOTE=signals;194259]Blu-ray Copy does just what its name says: it makes a Copy of a Blu-ray as a Blu-ray. You will need Cinavia Removal whether you write the output to a disc or a folder, depending on your player software.[/QUOTE]
No you don't. If you make a Blu-ray copy, the copy will continue to have Cinavia.

There are media player devices that will play BD ISO files (no need for a disc) and they will not be affected, as the requirement for Cinavia detection is only for hardware Blu-ray players and M$ software programs like PowerDVD.

MrVideo

[QUOTE=96734-dvd;194268]so being stuck at 42% is probably due to cinavia?[/QUOTE]
It isn't. Cinavia is in the audio stream and the audio stream is just copied (unless you check the remove HD audio box, in which case only the audio core is copied).