I first start by saying I don’t have Apple TV.
But I do read here and follow the progress of it
480p seems very odd, as streamfab has been updated to support up to 4k for Apple TV.
(https://streamfab.dvdfab.cn/apple-tv-downloader.htm)
You could try uninstalling, then installing the latest version again.
If that doesn’t help, then close streamfab and delete the streamfab temp folder, usually located at:
%HOMEPATH%\Documents\DVDFab\StreamFab\
Disregard, as the OP has Mac version.
There is a good chance, if it’s the Mac version, it doesn’t work.
Other than that, maybe someone who has Apple TV can give more insight.