Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Audio Sync problem

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    BD Ripper (3D Plus) Audio Sync problem

    I've ripped a couple hundred Blu-Ray DVDs to m2ts format. I have one which I have an audio sync problem that I have not been able to fix, the movie is Deja Vu. The main audio track is PCM but it also has a AC-3/5.1 secondary track. I've done an m2ts.passthrough rip of the PCM audio track and the audio is out of sync.

    ------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


    6m 16.58s: create config(5)
    6m 16.58s: convert profile(m2ts.passthrough)
    6m 16.58s: blu-ray playlist(30) angle(0) chapter(1->17)
    6m 16.58s: stream(4113,VC-1,0) stream(4352,LPCM,0)
    6m 16.61s: processing source(00048.m2ts)
    8m 14.92s: processing source(00049.m2ts)
    10m 13.36s: processing source(00035.m2ts)
    11m 26.51s: processing source(00037.m2ts)
    14m 10.98s: processing source(00039.m2ts)
    15m 10.09s: processing source(00061.m2ts)
    15m 56.00s: processing source(00032.m2ts)
    18m 07.68s: processing source(00034.m2ts)
    18m 34.53s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
    18m 52.30s: processing source(00036.m2ts)
    19m 38.77s: processing source(00038.m2ts)
    21m 25.37s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
    23m 59.81s: processing source(00041.m2ts)
    26m 18.79s:


    ------ finish mobile work ------

    If I try an m2ts.passthrough on the AC3/5.1 track there is no audio track on the m2ts file. I get video but no audio. I then tried an m2ts.ac3.high_quality rip against the AC3/5.1 trck and the audio was out of sync.

    ------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


    174m 54.14s: create config(5)
    174m 54.14s: convert profile(m2ts.ac3.high_quality)
    174m 54.14s: blu-ray playlist(30) angle(0) chapter(1->17)
    174m 54.14s: stream(4113,VC-1,1) stream(4353,AC3,1)
    174m 54.15s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
    174m 54.17s: processing source(00048.m2ts)
    174m 54.17s: using software decoder(vc1 multi-thread)
    174m 55.18s: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(22000)
    180m 55.45s: processing source(00049.m2ts)
    189m 26.52s: processing source(00035.m2ts)
    196m 51.78s: processing source(00037.m2ts)
    214m 44.91s: processing source(00039.m2ts)
    223m 53.52s: processing source(00061.m2ts)
    231m 30.65s: processing source(00032.m2ts)
    254m 46.47s: processing source(00034.m2ts)
    259m 32.58s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
    262m 38.98s: processing source(00036.m2ts)
    270m 52.34s: processing source(00038.m2ts)
    288m 57.49s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
    311m 39.62s: processing source(00041.m2ts)
    329m 02.73s:


    ------ finish mobile work ------

    I've also tried the same m2ts.ac3.high_quality profile against the PCM track and the audio is out of sync.

    #2
    Deja Vu audio sync has been a perennial problem since it was originally released on DVD.

    In fact it is one of my test DVD's to see whether Fab is behaving itself.

    Perhaps one of the "OLD HEADS" that have a BR copy would like to comment?
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy." - Benjamin Franklin 1706-1790

    Comment


      #3
      BD Ripper Audio Sync problem

      Here's a repost with the top portion of the log file for each rip:

      This is a rip of the PCM audio track with m2ts.passthrough:

      DVDFab 8.0.8.5 (2011/03/20 21:50:40)

      0m 00.71s: option dvd2dvd 1 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
      0m 34.16s: detected blu-ray
      0m 34.16s: drive X
      0m 34.16s: blu-ray type 1
      0m 34.16s: volume label 24585238_DEJA_VU
      0m 37.48s: detected blu-ray
      0m 37.48s: drive X
      0m 37.48s: blu-ray type 1
      0m 37.48s: volume label 24585238_DEJA_VU
      0m 41.43s: root 58234708_DEJA_VU:24585238_DEJA_VU:LOGICAL_VOLUME_I D:LOGICAL_VOLUME_ID
      0m 42.57s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
      0m 42.91s: got discinfo
      0m 43.07s: got bdmv
      0m 43.07s: got agid 0
      0m 43.13s: sent host cert chal
      0m 43.13s: got drive cert chal
      0m 43.15s: BEC 0
      0m 43.15s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0128
      0m 43.22s: got drive key
      0m 43.46s: got host key signature
      0m 43.46s: verified drive signature
      0m 43.46s: verified host signature
      0m 43.54s: sent host signature and key point
      0m 43.55s: got bus key
      0m 44.94s: got volume id
      0m 44.94s: got volume id mac
      0m 44.94s: volume id is correct
      0m 44.94s: got vid
      0m 45.08s: blu-ray 1A1074CC884F591912F067661E217F7A543D27F9
      0m 46.03s: D 636C7343
      0m 46.03s: got vuk
      0m 46.39s: got unit key 1
      1m 11.72s: got extended bdinfo
      1m 11.72s: opened blu-ray
      2m 07.82s:

      ------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


      6m 16.58s: create config(5)
      6m 16.58s: convert profile(m2ts.passthrough)
      6m 16.58s: blu-ray playlist(30) angle(0) chapter(1->17)
      6m 16.58s: stream(4113,VC-1,0) stream(4352,LPCM,0)
      6m 16.61s: processing source(00048.m2ts)
      8m 14.92s: processing source(00049.m2ts)
      10m 13.36s: processing source(00035.m2ts)
      11m 26.51s: processing source(00037.m2ts)
      14m 10.98s: processing source(00039.m2ts)
      15m 10.09s: processing source(00061.m2ts)
      15m 56.00s: processing source(00032.m2ts)
      18m 07.68s: processing source(00034.m2ts)
      18m 34.53s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
      18m 52.30s: processing source(00036.m2ts)
      19m 38.77s: processing source(00038.m2ts)
      21m 25.37s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
      23m 59.81s: processing source(00041.m2ts)
      26m 18.79s:


      ------ finish mobile work ------


      27m 27.79s:


      This is a rip of the AC3/5.1 audio track using m2ts.ac3.high_quality. There is no top portion since I didn't remove the disc and just did another rip following the one above with the different settings:
      ------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


      28m 45.87s: create config(5)
      28m 45.87s: convert profile(m2ts.ac3.high_quality)
      28m 45.87s: blu-ray playlist(30) angle(0) chapter(1->17)
      28m 45.87s: stream(4113,VC-1,1) stream(4353,AC3,1)
      28m 45.90s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
      28m 45.93s: processing source(00048.m2ts)
      28m 45.93s: using software decoder(vc1 multi-thread)
      28m 46.94s: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(24000)
      35m 04.28s: processing source(00049.m2ts)
      43m 42.40s: processing source(00035.m2ts)
      51m 44.32s: processing source(00037.m2ts)
      71m 00.37s: processing source(00039.m2ts)
      80m 46.82s: processing source(00061.m2ts)
      88m 35.92s: processing source(00032.m2ts)
      112m 31.50s: processing source(00034.m2ts)
      117m 25.98s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
      120m 39.67s: processing source(00036.m2ts)
      129m 05.44s: processing source(00038.m2ts)
      147m 33.55s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
      170m 41.43s: processing source(00041.m2ts)
      188m 24.51s:


      ------ finish mobile work ------

      Comment


        #4
        BD Ripper Audio Sync problem

        For what it is worth, I just used the same settings on the Coyote Ugly DVD, which had the same PCM audio track and other similar audio tracks as Deja Vu and the result was perfect. There is definently something with how DVDfab is ripping Deja Vu. Tomorrow I may try to rip it to DVD format and see if that works.

        Here's the Coyote Ugly log:

        DVDFab 8.0.8.5 (2011/03/23 06:36:30)

        0m 00.70s: option dvd2dvd 1 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
        0m 06.64s: detected blu-ray
        0m 06.64s: drive X
        0m 06.64s: blu-ray type 1
        0m 06.64s: volume label COYNDND11
        0m 07.81s: detected blu-ray
        0m 07.81s: drive X
        0m 07.81s: blu-ray type 1
        0m 07.81s: volume label COYNDND11
        0m 08.56s: root 8CA33E1C8BFCE4F7_VOLUME_SET_ID:COYNDND11:COYNDND11 :COYNDND11
        0m 09.23s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
        0m 11.41s: got discinfo
        0m 11.46s: got bdmv
        0m 11.46s: got agid 0
        0m 11.52s: sent host cert chal
        0m 11.52s: got drive cert chal
        0m 11.52s: BEC 0
        0m 11.52s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0128
        0m 11.60s: got drive key
        0m 11.85s: got host key signature
        0m 11.85s: verified drive signature
        0m 11.85s: verified host signature
        0m 11.91s: sent host signature and key point
        0m 11.93s: got bus key
        0m 14.08s: got volume id
        0m 14.08s: got volume id mac
        0m 14.08s: volume id is correct
        0m 14.08s: got vid
        0m 15.97s: blu-ray 4F92FCCD460888428F205A55014A457D1A8A6A19
        0m 16.80s: D 8BBF8BA0
        0m 16.81s: got vuk
        0m 17.11s: got unit key 1
        0m 32.71s: got extended bdinfo
        0m 32.71s: opened blu-ray
        2m 36.48s:


        ------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


        2m 36.48s: create config(5)
        2m 36.48s: convert profile(m2ts.ac3.high_quality)
        2m 36.48s: blu-ray playlist(0) angle(0) chapter(1->29)
        2m 36.48s: stream(4113,AVC,1) stream(4352,LPCM,1)
        2m 36.50s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
        2m 36.53s: processing source(00000.m2ts)
        2m 36.53s: using software decoder(h264 multi-thread)
        2m 37.54s: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(24000)
        134m 10.16s:


        ------ finish mobile work ------

        Comment


          #5
          Audio Sync problem

          I ripped my Deja Vu Blu Ray to a 9Gig DVD format. Then ripped that to VOB format and it works perfectly. If DVDFab can rip it down to a normal DVD format it ought to be able to rip it to m2ts without getting the audi/video out of sync. I'll retest on a future release of DVDFab.

          Comment


            #6
            BD Ripper Audio Synch Problem

            I've just had the same problem with 'STONE' --- No previous problems at all with other even newer rips(BD to PS3 and AC3 True 5.1 HD)) --- I'm hoping that this is a 'one off' as I'll be trying out the latest BD releases (Black Swan, Tangled etc) in the next couple of days --- I downloaded 'Infomedia' and all seems to be as it's supposed to be but ....... Any suggestions would be welcome. --- I don't bother with DVD rips any more - not good enough video quality

            Also, I should know better but I have a tendency to play with settings, which I really should'nt do without first noting what the original settings were...... Can anyone confirm that 448 kbs is the correct (or default) setting for the Audio Format AAC bitrate?

            Finally --- Does anyone know if there is is likely to be a discernable difference in audio quality between AC3 True 5.1 HD and AC3.2 --- I have a Yamaha/Bose multi channel audio system

            Comment


              #7
              Hi jbinkley60
              I am not sure if this will help but, have you tried unticking the Enable Lightning Recoding in A/VCodec, to see if it makes any difference?
              CBR929
              Even if it's a little thing, do something for those who have need of help, something for which you get no pay but the privilege of doing it.


              Setting Up ImgBurn and DVDFab to work together

              Tips for Posting DVDFab Logs in the Forum

              Comment


                #8
                Audio Sync problem

                Lightning recording is enabled. I may try disabling it to see if it makes a difference.

                Comment


                  #9
                  I am having the same problem. I ripped Tangled and it went all the way through. I watch it and the audio is not synced at all.

                  Any ideas?

                  Adam

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by jegesmaci View Post
                    I am having the same problem. I ripped Tangled and it went all the way through. I watch it and the audio is not synced at all.

                    Any ideas?

                    Adam
                    Hi jegesmaci
                    Have no ideas without more information and also logs the default location is:
                    For Win7 C:\Users\User Name\My Documents\DVDFab\Log
                    or Vista C:\Users\User Name\Documents\DVDFab\Log
                    or for XP C:\Documents and Settings\User Name\My Documents\DVDFab\Log
                    Please use attachment button and attach your most recent, Internal and Burn log(s) and post right here.
                    CBR929
                    Even if it's a little thing, do something for those who have need of help, something for which you get no pay but the privilege of doing it.


                    Setting Up ImgBurn and DVDFab to work together

                    Tips for Posting DVDFab Logs in the Forum

                    Comment


                      #11
                      I am also having audio sync problems with Star Trek TNG DVD's.. should i post my log's, problems, etc.. in this thread or start a new one? I want to be as little of a bother as possible and make things as easy as possible for anyone willing to help me with my issue..

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Sorry it took me some time. I tried again to burn Tangled and same thing happened.

                        Here are the logs.

                        I really appreciate your help.

                        Adam
                        Attached Files

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by edluver216 View Post
                          I am also having audio sync problems with Star Trek TNG DVD's.. should i post my log's, problems, etc.. in this thread or start a new one? I want to be as little of a bother as possible and make things as easy as possible for anyone willing to help me with my issue..
                          Hi edluver216
                          Yes, please post your logs in a new thread the default location is:
                          For Win7 C:\Users\User Name\My Documents\DVDFab\Log
                          or Vista C:\Users\User Name\Documents\DVDFab\Log
                          or for XP C:\Documents and Settings\User Name\My Documents\DVDFab\Log
                          Please use attachment button and attach your most recent, Internal and Burn log(s) and post right here.
                          You are no bother, as this it what the forum is here for.
                          CBR929
                          Even if it's a little thing, do something for those who have need of help, something for which you get no pay but the privilege of doing it.


                          Setting Up ImgBurn and DVDFab to work together

                          Tips for Posting DVDFab Logs in the Forum

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Hi jegesmaci
                            Please download MediaInfo found here http://mediainfo.sourceforge.net/en and scan your video source to find the frame rate and when on the Ripper main page click the edit button near the bottom right, and make sure that you choose the same frame rate as your original source and try again.
                            CBR929
                            Even if it's a little thing, do something for those who have need of help, something for which you get no pay but the privilege of doing it.


                            Setting Up ImgBurn and DVDFab to work together

                            Tips for Posting DVDFab Logs in the Forum

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Thank you CBR929. Do I scan the DVD in the drive or scan the already ripped file?

                              Thanks,

                              Adam

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X