BD Ripper (3D Plus) PS3 'Choppy Video'

[whaleshark]

Not a new thread but the newly issued 8129 Beta mentioned that the PS3 BD Ripper may have had a fix applied for this (Framerate fixed at 23.976). Sadly, not true The 'choppy video' phenomenon is still there with 8129 but a BD rip of the same clip done with my old and trusted standby 8085, streamed perfectly smoothly with no flaws at all. FYI, I am using CUDA and Software + CUDA for decode and encode --- So developers or moderators, was the fix applied to 8129 supposed to address the 'choppiness' or is this still on the 'to do list'?

Thanks

[whaleshark]

PS3 Choppy Video - Log Files

Sorry, I forgot to post the relevant log files. Here they are;

2011-10-20 18:34:43 ---- ******************** Log session stop 20-Oct 18:34:43.584 PID 3288********************
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info Current Drive selected : 1:0:0 - HL-DT-ST BDDVDRW CH10LS20 1.00 [E] (Ide)
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info Using Advanced SPTI interface
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info System default language : English (United States)
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info User default language : English (Canada)
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info DLL Version : 4.0.15.480
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info DLL : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8\vso_hwe.dll
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info Version : 8, 0, 8, 5
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info ExeName : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8\DVDFab.exe
2011-10-20 18:17:15 Info OS : Microsoft Windows 7 Professional (Build 7601: Service Pack 1)
2011-10-20 18:17:15 ---- ******************** Log session start 20-Oct 18:17:15.008 PID 3288********************



2011-10-20 18:15:19 ---- ******************** Log session stop 20-Oct 18:15:19.274 PID 2792********************
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info Current Drive selected : 1:0:0 - HL-DT-ST BDDVDRW CH10LS20 1.00 [E] (Ide)
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info Using Advanced SPTI interface
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info System default language : English (United States)
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info User default language : English (Canada)
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info DLL Version : 4.0.20.488
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info DLL : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8 Qt\vso_hwe.dll
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info Version : 8, 1, 2, 9
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info ExeName : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8 Qt\DVDFab.exe
2011-10-20 17:51:56 Info OS : Microsoft Windows 7 Professional (Build 7601: Service Pack 1)
2011-10-20 17:51:56 ---- ******************** Log session start 20-Oct 17:51:56.451 PID 2792********************



DVDFab 8.0.8.5 (2011/10/20 18:18:43)

0m 01.20s: option dvd2dvd 0 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 0 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 05.27s: detected blu-ray
0m 05.27s: drive E
0m 05.27s: blu-ray type 1
0m 05.27s: volume label GLADIATOR_D1
0m 07.23s: root 8CBE0F006B512098_VOLUME_SET_ID:GLADIATOR_D1:GLADIA TOR_D1:GLADIATOR_D1
0m 08.06s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
0m 09.11s: got discinfo
0m 09.22s: got bdmv
0m 09.22s: got agid 0
0m 09.23s: failed to send host certificate: sensekey 05 asc 6F acsq 00
0m 09.28s: blu-ray 262244E8C4747B200635F97424777927AC72D43F
0m 10.40s: D 7808D83A
0m 10.40s: E F8A0E9B1
0m 10.40s: got vuk
0m 10.73s: got unit key 7
0m 56.08s: got extended bdinfo
0m 56.08s: opened blu-ray
1m 53.02s:


------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


1m 53.02s: create config(5)
1m 53.02s: convert profile(ps3.mp4.hd)
1m 53.02s: blu-ray playlist(300) angle(0) chapter(1->1)
1m 53.02s: stream(4113,AVC,1) stream(4352,DTS-HD MA,1) stream(4608,PGS,4)
1m 53.03s: not set correct fourcc for video(28)
1m 53.03s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
1m 53.05s: subpicture preset(1), mode(0)
1m 53.08s: processing source(00201.m2ts)
1m 53.08s: try to use gpu acceleration(1) for video decoding
1m 53.11s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video decoding enabled
1m 53.14s: h264 encode: using official CUDA encoder
1m 53.16s: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(5634)
1m 53.28s: subpicture(4608) mode(0)
1m 53.28s: connect to sub render filter
12m 40.77s:


------ finish mobile work ------



DVDFab 8.1.2.9 (2011/10/20 17:51:49)

0m 01.56s: Qt Translator file load success
0m 01.90s: option dvd2dvd 0 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 0 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 11.91s: detected blu-ray
0m 11.91s: drive E
0m 11.91s: blu-ray type 1
0m 11.91s: volume label GLADIATOR_D1
0m 12.26s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
0m 15.16s: got discinfo
0m 15.42s: got bdmv
0m 15.44s: Vendor: HL-DT-ST
0m 15.44s: Product: BDDVDRW CH10LS20
0m 15.44s: Revision: 1.00
0m 15.44s: Vendor specific: 4
0m 15.44s: AACS version: 1
0m 15.44s: Number of concurrent AGIDs: 1
0m 15.44s: Supports bus encryption: NO
0m 15.44s: Supports binding nonce generation: YES
0m 15.44s: Supports Hybrid discs: NO
0m 15.44s: got agid 0
0m 15.46s: sent host cert chal
0m 15.47s: got drive cert chal
0m 15.47s: BEC 0
0m 15.47s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0116
0m 15.50s: got drive key
0m 16.53s: got host key signature
0m 16.53s: verified drive signature
0m 16.53s: verified host signature
0m 16.56s: sent host signature and key point
0m 16.56s: got bus key
0m 16.58s: got agid 0
0m 16.59s: sent host cert chal
0m 16.59s: got drive cert chal
0m 16.59s: BEC 0
0m 16.59s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0116
0m 16.63s: got drive key
0m 16.63s: got host key signature
0m 16.63s: verified drive signature
0m 16.64s: verified host signature
0m 16.67s: sent host signature and key point
0m 16.67s: got bus key
0m 16.67s: got volume id
0m 16.67s: got volume id mac
0m 16.67s: volume id is correct
0m 16.67s: got vid
0m 16.77s: blu-ray 262244E8C4747B200635F97424777927AC72D43F
0m 17.27s: cert BEE=0x00 same
0m 17.27s: got vuk
0m 17.27s: got unit key 7
1m 02.24s: got extended bdinfo
1m 02.24s: opened blu-ray
2m 07.32s:


------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


2m 07.32s: info: create config(5)
2m 07.32s: info: convert profile(ps3.mp4.hd)
2m 07.32s: info: bluray playlist(300),angle(0),chapter(1->1),3D(0)
2m 07.32s: info: streams((4113.2)(4352.2)(4608.8))
2m 07.36s: info: not set correct fourcc for video(28)
2m 07.36s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
2m 07.36s: info: subpicture preset(1), mode(0)
2m 07.36s: try to use gpu acceleration(1) for video decoding
2m 07.36s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video decoding enabled
2m 07.39s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video encoding enabled
2m 07.39s: info: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(5635)
2m 07.51s: info: subpicture(4608) mode(0)
2m 07.51s: info: connect to sub render filter
2m 07.53s: info: processing source(00201.m2ts)
13m 34.15s:


------ finish mobile work ------

[terry5]

Hi whaleshark ,
Please Open Fab click the Click the Green √ at top right corner of the DVDFab screen, and open Common Settings > General >A/V Codec, select "Disable all GPU codecs for decoding and encoding" and try it again.

[whaleshark]

PS3 BD Ripper Choppy Video

Hi Terry - I did as you requested with the same result of 'choppy video' when streamed. The only thing is that the rate of ripping is much slower (approx 24 FPS with Software as opposed to 48 to 50 FPS with GPU - twice as long)

For information, here are the the main summary points;

1) When streamed over my 'primary' PS3 which is 'hard wired' to my 1GB internal network, there is no evidence of 'choppy' video with either software or GPU encode/decode

2) When streamed over my 'Secondary' PS3 which is 'wired through a NETGEAR Powerline adaptor' to my 1GB internal network, the 'choppy' video with either software or GPU encode/decode

3) Both PS3's are fully updated

4) It seems that only the first 3 to 5 minutes of the BD rip is subjected to this choppy video - if the 'view' button is used to skip ahead a few minutes, the the streaming is smooth on either software or GPU encode/decode

5) If the rip is done to MKV and then converted to VOB (using mkv2vob) then the streaming is fine even though the transfer rate is much higher - so it seems to be a PS3 encode/decode problem

6) Using 8085 is fine - no problems in streaming

7) I have tried out rips on a friends PS3 streaming system and found the same results - Choppy video on any version after 8085

8) If the rip is 'copied' to the local PS3 HDD then there is no 'choppy' video on playback but of course, the streaming network is not being used......

9) Here is the latest logfile

2011-10-24 10:39:33 ---- ******************** Log session stop 24-Oct 10:39:33.545 PID 4312********************
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info Current Drive selected : 1:0:0 - HL-DT-ST BDDVDRW CH10LS20 1.00 [E] (Ide)
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info Using Advanced SPTI interface
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info System default language : English (United States)
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info User default language : English (Canada)
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info DLL Version : 4.0.20.488
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info DLL : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8 Qt\vso_hwe.dll
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info Version : 8, 1, 2, 9
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info ExeName : C:\Program Files (x86)\DVDFab 8 Qt\DVDFab.exe
2011-10-24 10:16:44 Info OS : Microsoft Windows 7 Professional (Build 7601: Service Pack 1)
2011-10-24 10:16:44 ---- ******************** Log session start 24-Oct 10:16:44.456 PID 4312********************


DVDFab 8.1.2.9 (2011/10/24 10:16:35)

0m 03.43s: Qt Translator file load success
0m 03.83s: option dvd2dvd 0 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 0 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 13.43s: detected blu-ray
0m 13.43s: drive E
0m 13.43s: blu-ray type 1
0m 13.43s: volume label GLADIATOR_D1
0m 13.82s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
0m 16.20s: got discinfo
0m 16.47s: got bdmv
0m 16.49s: Vendor: HL-DT-ST
0m 16.49s: Product: BDDVDRW CH10LS20
0m 16.49s: Revision: 1.00
0m 16.49s: Vendor specific: 4
0m 16.49s: AACS version: 1
0m 16.49s: Number of concurrent AGIDs: 1
0m 16.49s: Supports bus encryption: NO
0m 16.49s: Supports binding nonce generation: YES
0m 16.49s: Supports Hybrid discs: NO
0m 16.49s: got agid 0
0m 16.50s: sent host cert chal
0m 16.50s: got drive cert chal
0m 16.50s: BEC 0
0m 16.52s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0116
0m 16.55s: got drive key
0m 17.58s: got host key signature
0m 17.58s: verified drive signature
0m 17.58s: verified host signature
0m 17.61s: sent host signature and key point
0m 17.61s: got bus key
0m 17.62s: got agid 0
0m 17.64s: sent host cert chal
0m 17.64s: got drive cert chal
0m 17.64s: BEC 0
0m 17.64s: DRIVE_VENDOR 0x0116
0m 17.67s: got drive key
0m 17.69s: got host key signature
0m 17.69s: verified drive signature
0m 17.69s: verified host signature
0m 17.72s: sent host signature and key point
0m 17.72s: got bus key
0m 17.72s: got volume id
0m 17.72s: got volume id mac
0m 17.72s: volume id is correct
0m 17.72s: got vid
0m 17.83s: blu-ray 262244E8C4747B200635F97424777927AC72D43F
0m 18.34s: cert BEE=0x00 same
0m 18.34s: got vuk
0m 18.34s: got unit key 7
1m 02.93s: got extended bdinfo
1m 02.93s: opened blu-ray
2m 38.48s:


------ begin mobile work(1/1) ------


2m 38.48s: info: create config(5)
2m 38.48s: info: convert profile(ps3.mp4.hd)
2m 38.48s: info: bluray playlist(300),angle(0),chapter(1->1),3D(0)
2m 38.48s: info: streams((4113.2)(4352.2)(4608.8))
2m 38.49s: info: not set correct fourcc for video(28)
2m 38.51s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
2m 38.51s: info: subpicture preset(1), mode(0)
2m 38.51s: info: enable multi-thread software decoder
2m 39.57s: info: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(5635)
2m 41.58s: info: subpicture(4608) mode(0)
2m 41.58s: info: connect to sub render filter
2m 52.53s: info: processing source(00201.m2ts)
22m 49.11s:


------ finish mobile work ------

[terry5]

From your description, the problem is the transmission between PS3 and other device, in a word. No issue when copy the rippered files into PS3 HD. I think playing source from other device need a high speed of transmission, which may be the issue why the video is choppy. You may change a high speed transfer line and try it again.

[whaleshark]

PS3 BD Ripper Choppy Video

Terry,

I think you are partially correct because if I 'hard wire' the internal 1 GB network directly to the secondary PS3, then the 'choppy video' disappears and all is well. I have explained this before -

BUT --- This does not explain why a PS3 BD rip of the same BD done with Version 8085 (Pre QT Series) streams perfectly over the present network? It also does not explain why an MKV file with a much higher indicated transmission rate streams perfectly

Why does 8085 stream perfectly and 8129 (and all other qt series versions) suffer from the 'choppy video' when a PS3 rip is done?

I am planning to hard wire the secondary PS3 but from an interest point of view I really would like to know why 8085 is okay and other versions are not.

Thank you for taking an interest in this