DVD Ripper Titles with Two Audio Tracks - Does not rip the right one

[captnvideo]

Hi, I just ripped a movie which had two audio tracks identically showing AC3/2. When previewing them, one had commentary and the other didn't. So I selected (checked) the one which did not have commentary on preview. But after the rip, I opened the MKV file and it had commentary. So somehow, the preview is mixing them up. Is this a bug or am I missing something?

Thank you.

captnvideo

[Mona]

Hi captnvideo, what is the name of the movie? Please take a screenshot of the audio tracks to show us too.
We will try to get the same one to reproduce the issue first.

[captnvideo]

Hi captnvideo, what is the name of the movie? Please take a screenshot of the audio tracks to show us too.
We will try to get the same one to reproduce the issue first.

Hi Mona:

The DVD BUSTER_KEATON_COLLECTION_DISC 1 contains two movies. The first one (Title 1 The Cameraman) is where there are two identical audio tracks shown (English AC-3/2). When I checked and previewed the top one, I heard the commentary. So I unchecked the top one and checked the bottom one. Again I previewed and heard no commentary. So from this one I created the rip. But the MKV file produced had the commentary. So I had to do it over again, unchecking the bottom audio track and checking the top one instead. Even though I heard commentary in the preview, the resulting MKV did not have it which is what I wanted.

Here is a screen print.

Thank You.

[Mona]

Thank you for the info, we will try to reproduce it first.

[captnvideo]

We can close this topic. No problem for me to rip with both audio tracks selected. On my OPPO there is an "Audio" button by which I can choose whether I want the commentary or not. I am learning.