BD Ripper (3D Plus) Trying to maintain Dolby TrueHD Audio

[digitalforce]

I am using Blu-Ray Ripper and even after trying MKV.remux or h.264.copyaudio, I can get DTS-HD to stay in the MKV but any Dolby TrueHD gets downmixed to Dolby Digital 5.1

Any tips on this? I have tried every setting I can find and Dolby TrueHD is not handled correctly by any program including DVDFab and HandBrake.



Thanks in advance!

[Wilson.Wang]

Hi,

Did you select the "Remove HD Audio" option when converting?
I've tried with True-HD 5.1 & 7.1, DVDFab all handled correctly.
Which version you are used? Fab8? Please download DVDFab 9 and have a try! http://forum.dvdfab.com/showthread.php?t=20639
If it still reproduce please post your log file.

Thanks!

Wilson

[digitalforce]

Oh -- Remove HD audio means "keep HD audio" ?

[Wilson.Wang]

No, check "Remove HD Audio" option will down True-HD to AC-3.
Keep HD audio, should uncheck the option.

Wilson

[glenns]

Willson here is a test log 15 mins. long of Total recall 2012 using 9.2.2.3 beta.I had audio sync problems with this movie when i converted the whole movie twice with and without all software checked in settings.It made no difference and the soundtrack converted to regular dolby digital 5.1 not dolby true 5.1.

I used m2ts normal audio copy.The 50 gig non compressed iso i made to hard drive has dolby true 5.1 and i don't have remove hd audio checked in settings.It converts to 5.1 Dolby digital not Dolby true and it has audio sync problems so Vivian says to use m2ts ac3 normal I converted using that profile to just to get rid of the audio sync problem that it did but without dolby true just regular dolby 5.1 sound.



DVDFab 9.0.2.3 (2013/02/01 00:35:38)

0m 00.02s: Start preload dll...
0m 00.13s: Load dll successful.
0m 00.13s: Start load fabplay dll...
0m 00.22s: Load fabplay dll successful.
0m 00.22s: Windows os type is: 12.
0m 00.22s: Transfer settings successful.
0m 00.46s: GPUAccelerate: 12351
0m 00.46s: CUDA cap: 1
0m 00.46s: Support coreavc decode: 0
0m 00.46s: Graphics info: NVIDIA GeForce GT 630 : 5.0 : 2.1
0m 00.47s: Qt Translator file load success
0m 00.53s: Start get sys number.
0m 00.53s: Serial number is: 00-21-97-4a-93-56
0m 00.54s: Reg URL link is: https://www.dvdfabstore.com/auth/v2/
0m 00.54s: Version is: 9023
0m 00.54s: Product is: 2
0m 00.54s: Connect type is: 0
0m 01.92s: Times of connecting error is: 0
0m 01.92s: Parse string is: 1:1314749059
0m 01.92s: Parse string is: 20:8263532095
0m 01.92s: Parse string is: 22:8260762964
0m 01.92s: Parse string is: 70:8260762964
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: 21:8260762964
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: 50:8260762964
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: 11:8260762964
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: 2:0
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: 61:2
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: OV:9022
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: BV:9018
0m 01.93s: Parse string is: S:bd5c18fefb68326d1aee0fc94161f9e7
0m 02.04s: End check info.
0m 02.04s: Load config successful.
0m 02.41s: Profile Manager :: Begin Load Profile
0m 02.41s: Init profile data driver sucessful.
0m 02.41s: Init GPU settings sucessful.
0m 02.41s: option dvd2dvd 0 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2dvd 1 file2bluray 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 02.42s: dvd2dvd:dvd2mobile:blu-ray2blu-ray:blu-ray2mobile:blu-ray23d:blu-ray2dvd:file2mobile:file2dvd:file2bluray:
0m 13.56s: Begin init preview play engine.
0m 13.57s: Init DirectShow engine successful.
0m 13.80s: Init burn engine successful.
0m 14.40s: opening drive H
0m 14.40s: opened i/o
0m 14.40s: got media type 16
0m 14.45s: got max lba 19083359
0m 14.63s: got disc type 20
0m 14.63s: type Blu-ray BDMV
0m 14.63s: volume label TOTAL_RECALL_2012
0m 15.18s: opening drive E
0m 15.24s: opened i/o
0m 15.25s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 15.26s: got max lba 0
0m 15.28s: opening drive F
0m 15.44s: opened i/o
0m 15.45s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 15.47s: got max lba 1151
0m 17.48s: got disc type 0
0m 17.54s: opening drive I
0m 17.54s: opened i/o
0m 17.55s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 17.55s: got max lba 0
0m 17.55s: opening drive J
0m 17.55s: opened i/o
0m 17.55s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 17.55s: got max lba 0
0m 17.74s: internal path H:/BDMV/
0m 18.22s: aacs 0 bd+ 0
0m 18.93s: Java protection is removed by StealthyClone anti-protection.
0m 18.94s: got discinfo
0m 19.37s: got bdmv
0m 19.40s: Profile Manager :: End Load Profile
0m 30.41s: got extended bdinfo
0m 30.41s: opened blu-ray
9m 07.36s: Start check Blu-ray Ripper register status.
9m 07.36s: End check Blu-ray Ripper register status: Enable
9m 07.47s: OPList at BD Ripper : (4113.2),(4352.1)
9m 07.47s: Blu-ray ripper check watermark flag: 0
9m 07.47s: ------------------ convert work begin(1/1) ------------------
9m 07.47s: info: create config(bluray2video)
9m 07.47s: info: use profile(m2ts.audiocopy.normal)
9m 07.48s: info: bluray playlist(800),angle(0),chapter(1->16),BDAV(no)
9m 07.48s: info: 3D working_mode(disable), 3D format(sbs_lef_right)
9m 07.76s: info: [Video]stream(4113) codec(h264) opcode(compress)
9m 07.77s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
9m 07.78s: info: [Audio]stream(4352) codec(truehd) opcode(copy)
9m 07.78s: info: SubMode(NoSub) -- Display only forced subpicture(false)
9m 07.93s: try to use gpu acceleration(1) for video decoding
9m 07.94s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video decoding enabled
9m 08.06s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video encoding enabled
9m 08.07s: info: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(5524)
9m 08.58s: info: processing source(00100.m2ts)
9m 46.46s: info: processing source(00526.m2ts)
10m 02.78s: info: processing source(00527.m2ts)
11m 30.53s: info: processing source(00528.m2ts)
11m 41.96s: info: processing source(00529.m2ts)
12m 37.45s: info: processing source(00530.m2ts)
15m 08.69s: info: processing source(00531.m2ts)
18m 56.79s: info: processing source(00532.m2ts)
19m 13.65s: info: processing source(00533.m2ts)
20m 08.09s: info: processing source(00534.m2ts)
21m 30.65s: info: processing source(00535.m2ts)
21m 51.76s: info: processing source(00536.m2ts)
22m 36.24s: ------------------ all convert work cancelled -------------------

[glenns]

Wilson:Here is another try using the m2ts audio copy normal profile.Theirs no Dolby true sound just Dolby digital 16 bit 48000hz soundtrack.The 50 gig iso has Dolby true 5.1 and the Dolby true light in my receiver lights up when playing the 50 gig iso but not the fab made m2ts file.

The second problem is the audio lags the video when using the above profile with or without using all software checked in the settings box.Movie name is (Total recall 2012) do you have this movie so you can try it and see if your result is the same? To get rid of the audio lag I had to use m2ts ac3 normal profile but theirs also no Dolby true just 5.1 Dolby with this profile.And like i said before i never check the remove HD sound box.




DVDFab 9.0.2.3 (2013/02/01 03:20:41)

0m 00.05s: Start preload dll...
0m 00.13s: Load dll successful.
0m 00.13s: Start load fabplay dll...
0m 00.23s: Load fabplay dll successful.
0m 00.23s: Windows os type is: 12.
0m 00.24s: Transfer settings successful.
0m 00.73s: GPUAccelerate: 12351
0m 00.73s: CUDA cap: 1
0m 00.74s: Support coreavc decode: 0
0m 00.74s: Graphics info: NVIDIA GeForce GT 630 : 5.0 : 2.1
0m 00.76s: Qt Translator file load success
0m 00.84s: Start get sys number.
0m 00.84s: Serial number is: 00-21-97-4a-93-56
0m 00.84s: Reg URL link is: https://www.dvdfabstore.com/auth/v2/
0m 00.84s: Version is: 9023
0m 00.84s: Product is: 2
0m 00.84s: Connect type is: 0
0m 02.29s: Times of connecting error is: 0
0m 02.29s: Parse string is: 1:1314749059
0m 02.29s: Parse string is: 20:8263532095
0m 02.30s: Parse string is: 22:8260762964
0m 02.30s: Parse string is: 70:8260762964
0m 02.31s: Parse string is: 21:8260762964
0m 02.31s: Parse string is: 50:8260762964
0m 02.31s: Parse string is: 11:8260762964
0m 02.32s: Parse string is: 2:0
0m 02.32s: Parse string is: 61:2
0m 02.32s: Parse string is: OV:9022
0m 02.32s: Parse string is: BV:9018
0m 02.32s: Parse string is: S:13228edee9d95c142410fbd34782ae2c
0m 02.35s: End check info.
0m 02.36s: Load config successful.
0m 02.84s: Profile Manager :: Begin Load Profile
0m 02.84s: Init profile data driver sucessful.
0m 02.84s: Init GPU settings sucessful.
0m 02.84s: option dvd2dvd 0 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 bd23d 1 bd2dvd 1 file2dvd 1 file2bluray 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 02.84s: dvd2dvd:dvd2mobile:blu-ray2blu-ray:blu-ray2mobile:blu-ray23d:blu-ray2dvd:file2mobile:file2dvd:file2bluray:
0m 15.17s: Begin init preview play engine.
0m 15.18s: Init DirectShow engine successful.
0m 15.52s: Init burn engine successful.
0m 16.20s: opening drive H
0m 16.20s: opened i/o
0m 16.20s: got media type 16
0m 16.24s: got max lba 19083359
0m 16.43s: got disc type 20
0m 16.43s: type Blu-ray BDMV
0m 16.43s: volume label TOTAL_RECALL_2012
0m 17.46s: opening drive E
0m 17.49s: opened i/o
0m 17.49s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 17.51s: got max lba 0
0m 17.54s: opening drive F
0m 17.70s: opened i/o
0m 17.71s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 17.72s: got max lba 1151
0m 19.74s: got disc type 0
0m 19.80s: opening drive I
0m 19.80s: opened i/o
0m 19.80s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 19.80s: got max lba 0
0m 19.80s: opening drive J
0m 19.80s: opened i/o
0m 19.80s: failed to detect media type: sensekey 00 asc 00 acsq 00
0m 19.81s: got max lba 0
0m 20.27s: internal path H:/BDMV/
0m 20.90s: aacs 0 bd+ 0
0m 21.65s: Java protection is removed by StealthyClone anti-protection.
0m 21.66s: got discinfo
0m 21.82s: Profile Manager :: End Load Profile
0m 22.08s: got bdmv
0m 33.54s: got extended bdinfo
0m 33.55s: opened blu-ray
2m 07.42s: Start check Blu-ray Ripper register status.
2m 07.42s: End check Blu-ray Ripper register status: Enable
2m 07.49s: OPList at BD Ripper : (4113.2),(4352.1)
2m 07.50s: Blu-ray ripper check watermark flag: 0
2m 07.50s: ------------------ convert work begin(1/1) ------------------
2m 07.51s: info: create config(bluray2video)
2m 07.51s: info: use profile(m2ts.audiocopy.normal)
2m 07.52s: info: bluray playlist(800),angle(0),chapter(1->16),BDAV(no)
2m 07.52s: info: 3D working_mode(disable), 3D format(sbs_lef_right)
2m 07.68s: info: [Video]stream(4113) codec(h264) opcode(compress)
2m 07.71s: info: set output video frame_rate(24000/1001)
2m 07.72s: info: [Audio]stream(4352) codec(truehd) opcode(copy)
2m 07.72s: info: SubMode(NoSub) -- Display only forced subpicture(false)
2m 07.93s: try to use gpu acceleration(1) for video decoding
2m 07.93s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video decoding enabled
2m 07.93s: CUDA GPU acceleration for video encoding enabled
2m 07.95s: info: h264_encode: encode param profile(2) level(41) bitrate(9207)
2m 08.44s: info: processing source(00100.m2ts)
2m 46.62s: info: processing source(00526.m2ts)
3m 02.49s: info: processing source(00527.m2ts)
4m 31.46s: info: processing source(00528.m2ts)
4m 43.82s: info: processing source(00529.m2ts)
5m 41.14s: info: processing source(00530.m2ts)
8m 14.32s: info: processing source(00531.m2ts)
12m 04.19s: info: processing source(00532.m2ts)
12m 20.67s: info: processing source(00533.m2ts)
13m 18.17s: info: processing source(00534.m2ts)
14m 42.69s: info: processing source(00535.m2ts)
15m 03.18s: info: processing source(00536.m2ts)
18m 55.05s: info: processing source(00537.m2ts)
21m 29.26s: info: processing source(00538.m2ts)
23m 43.90s: info: processing source(00539.m2ts)
25m 12.21s: info: processing source(00540.m2ts)
25m 26.33s: info: processing source(00541.m2ts)
27m 45.21s: info: processing source(00542.m2ts)
30m 15.05s: info: processing source(00543.m2ts)
30m 26.98s: info: processing source(00544.m2ts)
32m 41.79s: info: processing source(00545.m2ts)
35m 25.18s: info: processing source(00546.m2ts)
35m 39.03s: info: processing source(00547.m2ts)
37m 32.63s: info: processing source(00548.m2ts)
38m 46.66s: info: processing source(00549.m2ts)
40m 07.44s: info: processing source(00550.m2ts)
40m 19.78s: info: processing source(00551.m2ts)
40m 49.03s: info: processing source(00552.m2ts)
41m 18.67s: info: processing source(00553.m2ts)
42m 29.86s: info: processing source(00554.m2ts)
43m 03.79s: info: processing source(00555.m2ts)
45m 31.30s: info: processing source(00556.m2ts)
47m 15.16s: info: processing source(00557.m2ts)
50m 49.96s: info: processing source(00558.m2ts)
54m 16.41s: info: processing source(00559.m2ts)
55m 04.19s: info: processing source(00561.m2ts)
55m 55.66s: info: processing source(00562.m2ts)
56m 16.20s: info: processing source(00563.m2ts)
56m 59.29s: info: processing source(00564.m2ts)
59m 58.41s: info: processing source(00565.m2ts)
60m 08.34s: info: processing source(00566.m2ts)
61m 41.07s: info: processing source(00567.m2ts)
62m 30.46s: info: processing source(00568.m2ts)
64m 17.34s: info: processing source(00569.m2ts)
67m 43.19s: info: processing source(00570.m2ts)
69m 20.41s: info: processing source(00571.m2ts)
70m 03.17s: info: processing source(00572.m2ts)
70m 16.27s: info: processing source(00573.m2ts)
71m 37.44s: info: processing source(00574.m2ts)
72m 23.53s: info: processing source(00575.m2ts)
72m 39.65s: info: processing source(00576.m2ts)
74m 04.64s: info: processing source(00644.m2ts)
77m 41.55s: info: processing source(00580.m2ts)
79m 41.73s: info: processing source(00581.m2ts)
85m 04.18s: info: processing source(00583.m2ts)
87m 18.17s: info: processing source(00584.m2ts)
87m 36.01s: info: processing source(00585.m2ts)
90m 29.76s: info: processing source(00586.m2ts)
90m 44.65s: info: processing source(00587.m2ts)
91m 52.59s: info: processing source(00588.m2ts)
92m 30.65s: info: processing source(00589.m2ts)
93m 10.45s: info: processing source(00590.m2ts)
97m 17.67s: info: processing source(00632.m2ts)
98m 36.63s: info: processing source(00633.m2ts)
98m 47.63s: info: processing source(00591.m2ts)
99m 17.82s: info: processing source(00592.m2ts)
104m 35.17s: info: processing source(00593.m2ts)
106m 48.29s: info: processing source(00594.m2ts)
107m 45.93s: info: processing source(00595.m2ts)
108m 19.37s: info: processing source(00596.m2ts)
114m 54.12s: ------------------ convert work finished ------------------

[Wilson.Wang]

Hi，glenns

Always converter True-HD to AC-3 with m2ts audiocopy profile，it's a bug really，I've reproduce this and report to our dev. Please wait some time to fix it.

And for the AV sync issue with TOTAL_RECALL_2012, we will check the issue when we get the source.

Sorry for this to trouble you!
Thanks!

Wilson

[Wilson.Wang]

Hi, digitalforce

How about you? Please tell us the result!
Thanks!

Wilson

[digitalforce]

I tried with DVDFab9 beta and now XBMC says it is Dolby TrueHD 7.1 but it won't decode it correctly. If I do just a straight passthrough rip with HandBrake or MakeMKV, it works just fine. I will post my log file later today.

[Wilson.Wang]

Hi, glenns

The issue of converting True-HD to AC-3 when ripper to m2ts.audiocopy is fixed in 9024. Please have a try!
Thanks!

Wilson

[glenns]

Wilson:That's great only thing is 9.0.2.4 is not out yet but i will give it a try as soon as it's up for download unless you have a special link for me .

The same movie has the audio lag problem did you put in overtime and get that fixed so soon also? I will try it even if the audio lag is still their because other people are having this problem with Dolby true and we all would like to see this one get fixed.Thanks for all your help Glenns.

[Wilson.Wang]

@glenns
http://forum.dvdfab.com/showthread.php?t=20715 Download from here.
Thanks for your suppor!

Wison

[glenns]

Great Wilson i have done the conversion and both the audio lag problem is fixed and the Dolby True converting to regular Dolby digital is also fixed.

Bravo now we only have one problem left that's a black level problem you can use the same movie to test this look at the end credits back with white words
you will see if you look at the 50 gig version the black level is much higher than any fab made profile using ripper.The fab made version looks washed out and so doe's the whole movie because the black level is not correct.We have another ongoing topic open http://forum.dvdfab.com/showthread.php?t=20249
can you come over and take a look please.Thank you for your on going support Glenns.