DVDFab 12.0.6.9 - MakeMKV Finds Subtitles DVDFab Can't

[jsinfate]

I just received a used DVD in the mail and when I did a copy DVDFab only found the Spanish subtitles. When I put the disc into MakeMKV it found the CC English subtitles.
Strange thing is that when you play the movie and enable subtitles, Spanish is the only one listed.

Is DVDFAb just not capable of finding Closed Captioned subtitles?
Attaching the screenshot of MakeMKV and of the subtitles I ripped since .srt files aren't allowed as uploads.

[october262]

I just received a used DVD in the mail and when I did a copy DVDFab only found the Spanish subtitles. When I put the disc into MakeMKV it found the CC English subtitles.
Strange thing is that when you play the movie and enable subtitles, Spanish is the only one listed.

Is DVDFAb just not capable of finding Closed Captioned subtitles?
Attaching the screenshot of MakeMKV and of the subtitles I ripped since .srt files aren't allowed as uploads.

try using dvd ripper - https://forum.dvdfab.cn/forum/softwa...ge#post391679=
post #2

[jsinfate]

Thank you for the reply. I don't want to convert it. To be honest I don't like the results from DVDFab's conversion settings. I just to work with the complete dvd but for some reason DVDFab can't do that.
I tried your suggestion but as you can see DVDFab ONLY sees Spanish subtitles.
This is a big issue. I am trying to make a perfect 1:1 copy of the DVD to my computer but isn't happening

[october262]

Thank you for the reply. I don't want to convert it. To be honest I don't like the results from DVDFab's conversion settings. I just to work with the complete dvd but for some reason DVDFab can't do that.
I tried your suggestion but as you can see DVDFab ONLY sees Spanish subtitles.
This is a big issue. I am trying to make a perfect 1:1 copy of the DVD to my computer but isn't happening

in your picture, click on the rocket ship and choose clone copy, it does a 1:1 copy, clone doesn't compress
the file so you will need to have a dual layer disc or choose iso file.

[jsinfate]

I tried that and they still do not show up. They are on the disc as Closed Captions so why aren't they transferring?

[october262]

I tried that and they still do not show up. They are on the disc as Closed Captions so why aren't they transferring?

what are you using to play the disc on ?? do the cc show if you play the disc on your PC ??

[jsinfate]

I'm using MPC-BE to play the DVD disc, the 1:1 copy I made and the full disc copy I made. How can they exist and MakeMKV extracts it but DVDFab and my player doesn't see the Closed Captions?