Star Wars 3 & 5

[K1LL3M]

What title/sub have you used for Sith and Empire on the Star Wars BDs?

On just these 2 rips using movie only I cant stop the commentators names appearing.

It appears that title 800(1) & 850(1) are the English text versions (don't know what the difference is but I have tried both) and the very last English sub-picture option is the force subs.

This worked fine for every other disk, but so far everything I try results in the the commentators names being displayed for these 2 disks

What am I missing here, what has worked for others?

[Wilson.Wang]

Hi,

Title 850(1) is OK, and you could select all Eng subs for the movie, the subs just a little space need.

Wilson

[signals]

K1LL3M

In Sith there are 5 english sub streams. #1 seems to be the only one that contains spoken dialog. Streams #10 and 11 are the subs for the two commentary audio tracks, 28&29 are also related to the commentary audio tracks but only identify the speaker by name in the top center of the frame. My guess is that they are forced on when either of the commentaries are chosen in the disc setup, so that you can tell who is speaking. I did not find any spoken dialog in any of the last 4, only #1, so if there are any forced subs for dialog they should be in there. I haven't looked at Empire yet.

As Wilson said, you can include them all with little size penalty, but make sure that none of them have the default arrow beside the sub stream checkbox or they will play every time and will have to be turned off manually.

[K1LL3M]

Thanks guys, have tried with options as Fab selects when opens, including all subs, and tried without, but still happening.

I did a full disc rip of these 2 and in plays ok in full disc mode, but it seems it doesn't matter what I do in Movie only mode, I get the commentator names displayed.

Just doesn't make any sense and its annoying, as I really only want the movie. I pretty much only ever rip movie, HD audio track and single sub track.