Saving Private Ryan shrinks to 11GB

[stinkfinger]

Ripped SPR to Full ISO then attempted to compress to a 25GB blank while backing up movie only. When finished it only totaled 11GB. Watched various parts of movie and it seems ok. Guessing picture quality isn't as good as if it was 25GB. Occasional distortion but doesnt' seem to bad. I've attached the logs. Any idea what happened? Picture seems ok on my 46" TV but I haven't tried on my 100" DLP projector. I'm thinking I'll be able to see the loss of quality there.


DVDFab 7.0.6.2 (2010/05/27 17:11:28)

0m 06.34s: option dvd2dvd 1 dvd2mobile 1 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 file2mobile 1 filemover 1
0m 16.48s: detected blu-ray
0m 16.48s: drive D
0m 16.48s: volume label SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
0m 19.53s: root 8CCBA72521000226_VOLUME_SET_ID:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN _1:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
0m 20.40s: aacs 1 bd+ 0
0m 22.79s: got discinfo
0m 22.87s: got bdmv
0m 22.89s: got agid
0m 22.90s: sent host cert chal
0m 22.90s: got drive cert chal
0m 22.93s: got drive key
0m 22.93s: got host key signature
0m 22.95s: verified drive signature
0m 22.95s: verified host signature
0m 22.98s: sent host signature and key point
0m 22.98s: got bus key
0m 22.98s: got volume id
0m 22.98s: got volume id mac
0m 22.98s: volume id is correct
0m 22.98s: got vid
0m 24.18s: got vuk
0m 24.18s: got unit key 7
0m 26.01s: got extended bdinfo
29m 12.75s: compress begin: Blu-ray groups clips(00045.m2ts,00040.m2ts,00046.m2ts), playtime(10168699 ms), size(43342 MB)
29m 12.76s: processing source(00045.m2ts)
29m 32.98s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
86m 06.39s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
124m 13.42s: detected blu-ray
124m 13.45s: iso E:\dvdfabb\SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1.iso
124m 13.45s: volume label SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
124m 13.50s: root 3CBB94BD0121FFA5:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1:SAVING_PRIV ATE_RYAN_1:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
124m 13.54s: aacs 0 bd+ 0
124m 13.62s: got discinfo
124m 13.64s: got bdmv
124m 13.71s: got extended bdinfo
125m 28.35s: detected blu-ray
125m 28.42s: drive D
125m 28.42s: volume label
146m 13.23s: compress begin: Blu-ray groups clips(00045.m2ts,00040.m2ts,00046.m2ts), playtime(10168699 ms), size(37118 MB)
146m 13.32s: processing source(00045.m2ts)
155m 59.04s: group(00045.m2ts ) playtime(43084 ms) source(160 MB) request(101 MB) real(96 MB) bitrate(17181 kbps)
155m 59.07s: request bitrate(-176.902 kbps) too small, using average bitrate to encode
155m 59.09s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
2230m 27.82s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
2238m 07.03s: group(00040.m2ts 00046.m2ts ) playtime(10125615 ms) source(36897 MB) request(23366 MB) real(11109 MB) bitrate(7049 kbps)
2238m 07.12s: compress finished: groups request(23463 MB, 23467 MB) real(11205 MB) average_bitrate(7049 kbps)

[signals]

Watch the output closely enough to make sure the entire movie is there, i.e. no chapters or groups of chapters missing. Has anybody else done this with similar results? This was almost the equivalent of making a BD-9 of it (which still look very good). I only have the DVD of SPR.

[stinkfinger]

I went through the movie chapter by chapter. I know the movie pretty well so it seemed all the chapters are there. Tonight I'll go through it closer(3hr movie so it takes a while). Notice at the end of the log where it says:

2238m 07.03s: group(00040.m2ts 00046.m2ts ) playtime(10125615 ms) source(36897 MB) request(23366 MB) real(11109 MB) bitrate(7049 kbps)
2238m 07.12s: compress finished: groups request(23463 MB, 23467 MB) real(11205 MB) average_bitrate(7049 kbps)

The request is for 23463 MB(which is to be expected) real 11205 MB is the result.

[jbejm]

I had the same problem with different movie. I post it on forum but I did not had any respond to my post.
The compression was showing 25.3 -> 23.1 (91%) but the final ISO file was only 13 gigs.
The file was bad when watching. It work in full backup (39 gigs) but not what I want it.

[fengtao]

We are checking this issue, thanks for reporting.

[fengtao]

Dear all,

Please try DVDFab 7067 to see the result:

http://www.dvdfab.com/download.htm

Best Regards,
Fengtao

[stinkfinger]

This movie is becoming my "White Whale." I've tried it with 7.0.6.7----7.0.6.6--- and even reverted back to 7.0.4.0 and still get the only about 11GB after shrinking. Only actually burnt it once though so not a huge deal. Thanks for any ideas or help. Here is the latest log with 7.0.6.7


DVDFab 7.0.6.7 (2010/06/02 19:22:25)

0m 00.84s: option dvd2dvd 1 dvd2mobile 0 bluray2bluray 1 bd2mobile 1 file2mobile 0 filemover 0
0m 18.25s: detected blu-ray
0m 18.25s: iso E:\dvdfabb\SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1.iso
0m 18.25s: volume label SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
0m 18.35s: root 3CBB94BD0121FFA5:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1:SAVING_PRIV ATE_RYAN_1:SAVING_PRIVATE_RYAN_1
0m 18.35s: aacs 0 bd+ 0
0m 18.35s: got discinfo
0m 18.35s: got bdmv
0m 18.53s: got extended bdinfo
21m 57.64s: compress begin: Blu-ray groups clips(00045.m2ts,00040.m2ts,00046.m2ts), playtime(10168699 ms), size(37118 MB)
21m 57.75s: processing source(00045.m2ts)
31m 39.50s: group(00045.m2ts ) playtime(43084 ms) source(160 MB) request(101 MB) real(95 MB) bitrate(17181 kbps)
31m 39.54s: processing source(00040.m2ts)
2063m 52.70s: group(00040.m2ts ) playtime(10101091 ms) source(36806 MB) request(23309 MB) real(11023 MB) bitrate(7003 kbps)
2063m 52.76s: warning: ggnode(00046.m2ts ) estimate_out_size > source_size(90.5554 MB), video_source(85.4978 MB), drop(0 MB), estimate_out_video(12338.6 MB)
2063m 52.79s: processing source(00046.m2ts)
2067m 43.57s: group(00046.m2ts ) playtime(24524 ms) source(90 MB) request(90 MB) real(25 MB) bitrate(7049 kbps)
2067m 43.59s: compress finished: groups request(23463 MB, 23501 MB) real(11145 MB) average_bitrate(7049 kbps)

[thisizbrian]

been trying spr as well with no success. it made 11gb folder with v7067.

[stinkfinger]

Thanks for replying. I was nervous I was the only one getting this problem and they'd just tell me to try the latest beta again. Hanks and SS must have put some extra time into the protection on this one!

[thisizbrian]

ya i think its something with the protection.

[stinkfinger]

Also I'm using the second version. The first had a sinc problem with the audio that was recalled.

[fengtao]

We have got the disc, working on it now.

[stinkfinger]

Thank you!

[millfieldlad]

I,m using the latest version 7.0.7.0 released june 8 and my file is also 12.5 gig. my output setting was for 22gig file

[stinkfinger]

I'm still having the same problem with this movie also. I tried using another program to shrink and was unsuccessful as well. My encode rate is always 7049 KBS which results in about 11 GBs.